How many pizza places are there in Fernandina Beach?

Eight, all listed on this page with a confirmed address, telephone number and official website. One is downtown, six are on the Sadler Road and 8th–14th Street corridors, and one is at the Omni shops on the south end.

Is there pizza in downtown Fernandina Beach?

One place: Arte Pizza at 109 North 3rd Street, a block off Centre Street. Every other pizzeria on the island needs a short drive from downtown.

Where is the best pizza on Amelia Island?

We do not rank restaurants and we publish no ratings or review scores. What we can tell you is where each of the eight is, which is the question that actually decides where you eat on a given evening.

Pizza in Fernandina Beach: All 8 Places

Key facts

Eight pizzerias operate on Amelia Island. Only one of them is downtown: the rest sit along Sadler Road and the 8th and 14th Street corridors, which is where the island's everyday eating actually happens, plus one at the south-end resort shops. Sorting them by address is more useful than ranking them.

Our picks

Arte Pizza

Downtown Fernandina Beach

Arte Pizza is a restaurant at 109 N 3rd Street. We have confirmed its address, phone number and website directly (2026-09-10); opening hours and prices are not confirmed, so we do not publish them here.

Moon River Pizza

Downtown Fernandina Beach

A by-the-slice and whole-pie pizza counter in downtown Fernandina Beach, on the casual, fast and inexpensive end of the district — the practical answer to feeding a family after a beach day without a full service.

Eight pizzerias for an island of thirteen miles, and the surprise is where they are not.

Only one is downtown

Arte Pizza at 109 North 3rd Street is the single pizzeria inside the historic district, a block off Centre Street. If you are staying downtown and want pizza on foot, that is the list.

Everything else is a drive — short, but a drive.

The Sadler Road and 8th–14th Street corridors

This is where the island's everyday eating happens, away from the Victorian storefronts:

Loop Pizza and Grill — 869 Sadler Road
V Pizza Fernandina — 2709 Sadler Road
Ops Pizza Kitchen and Cafe — 2030 South 8th Street
Moon River Pizza — 929 South 14th Street
Savannah Pizza Company — 1925 South 14th Street
Townies Pizzeria and Deli — 819 TJ Courson Road

Sadler Road is the cross-island route between the beach and the mainland bridge, so two of these are convenient in a way that has nothing to do with downtown: you pass them.

The south end

Natural Slice is at the Omni shops, 75 Amelia Village Circle. If you are staying at the south-end resorts, that is the pizza you can reach without getting back in the car — and see south end and resorts for the rest of what is down there.

Why we are not ranking these

Because we would be making it up. We hold no confirmed menus, prices, oven types or hours for any pizzeria on this island, and a ranking built on nothing is worse than a list built on addresses. Pizza is also the most reliable way to feed a group here without booking anything, which is why it turns up on cheap eats and with kids too.

We publish no opening hours, prices or menus for any restaurant on this island, because we have confirmed none, and several kitchens here close days of the week out of season. What every venue below does carry is an address, a telephone number and an official website, each checked on 10 September 2026. Ring before you walk.

More on amelia island dining

Part of Amelia Island dining.

Frequently asked questions

How many pizza places are there in Fernandina Beach?: Eight, all listed on this page with a confirmed address, telephone number and official website. One is downtown, six are on the Sadler Road and 8th–14th Street corridors, and one is at the Omni shops on the south end.
Is there pizza in downtown Fernandina Beach?: One place: Arte Pizza at 109 North 3rd Street, a block off Centre Street. Every other pizzeria on the island needs a short drive from downtown.
Where is the best pizza on Amelia Island?: We do not rank restaurants and we publish no ratings or review scores. What we can tell you is where each of the eight is, which is the question that actually decides where you eat on a given evening.