Is there a bakery in Fernandina Beach?

Yes — five bakeries and sweet shops are listed here with a confirmed address, telephone number and official website, three of them inside the downtown historic district.

Where can you get donuts in Fernandina Beach?

Vintage Donuts at 503A Centre Street, downtown. We publish no opening hours for it, and a donut shop is exactly the sort of business that sells out and closes early, so ring first.

Is there an ice cream shop on Amelia Island?

Very likely, but we have not confirmed one against a primary source, so there is none on this page. We would rather show you the gap than list a business we cannot stand behind.

Bakeries in Fernandina Beach: 5 Places

Key facts

Five places on Amelia Island make or sell the sweet end: a bake shop and a donut shop in the historic district, a fudge counter on Centre Street, a made-to-order baker on South 8th Street and a chocolatier on Sadler Road. We have confirmed no ice cream shop, which is a gap in our records rather than a claim about the island.

Our picks

Nana Teresa's Bake Shop

Downtown Fernandina Beach

Nana Teresa's Bake Shop is a bakery at 13 N 3rd Street. We have confirmed its address, phone number and website directly (2026-09-10); opening hours and prices are not confirmed, so we do not publish them here.

Vintage Donuts

Downtown Fernandina Beach

Vintage Donuts is a bakery at 503A Centre Street. We have confirmed its address, phone number and website directly (2026-09-10); opening hours and prices are not confirmed, so we do not publish them here.

Five places, doing four different jobs.

Downtown, walkable from Centre Street

Nana Teresa's Bake Shop — 13 North 3rd Street. The walk-in, look-in-the-case bake shop.
Vintage Donuts — 503A Centre Street.
Fernandina's Fantastic Fudge — 218 Centre Street. A tourist-street fudge counter, and entirely honest about being one.

Three shops inside a few blocks, which makes the sweet half of a downtown morning easy to plan — pair it with coffee and the downtown dining guide.

Off the main street

A Will and A Whisk — 1853 South 8th Street. This is the made-to-order side of the business rather than a pastry case, which is a different transaction: ring it if you need a cake for something, not something sweet for now. People turn up at the wrong one.
Peterbrooke Chocolatier — 1427 Sadler Road.

A gap we are not going to paper over

There is no ice cream shop on this page. Our confirmed dataset — 366 island businesses checked against operator websites and the visitor bureau's partner directory on 10 September 2026 — does not contain one, so we have nothing to list. That is a hole in our records, not a statement about the island, and when we confirm one it will appear here.

We publish no opening hours, prices or menus for any restaurant on this island, because we have confirmed none, and several kitchens here close days of the week out of season. What every venue below does carry is an address, a telephone number and an official website, each checked on 10 September 2026. Ring before you walk.

More on amelia island dining

Part of Amelia Island dining.

Frequently asked questions

Is there a bakery in Fernandina Beach?: Yes — five bakeries and sweet shops are listed here with a confirmed address, telephone number and official website, three of them inside the downtown historic district.
Where can you get donuts in Fernandina Beach?: Vintage Donuts at 503A Centre Street, downtown. We publish no opening hours for it, and a donut shop is exactly the sort of business that sells out and closes early, so ring first.
Is there an ice cream shop on Amelia Island?: Very likely, but we have not confirmed one against a primary source, so there is none on this page. We would rather show you the gap than list a business we cannot stand behind.