Amelia Island has three lodging zones. Downtown Fernandina Beach means walking to twenty restaurants and driving two miles to the sand; the south-end resorts mean the reverse; oceanside Fletcher Avenue means a short drive to both, and is the option most visitors never consider.
A shingle-style oceanfront inn on South Fletcher Avenue in Fernandina Beach, built in the manner of a 1890s Nantucket lifesaving station. Small, directly on the sand, with breakfast included and a wraparound porch facing the Atlantic.
The island's largest full-service resort, occupying a big oceanfront and marsh parcel on the south end within the former Amelia Island Plantation. Golf, tennis, pools, a nature centre, multiple restaurants and direct beach access behind the dune.
An oceanfront luxury resort on the island's Summer Beach stretch, with its own dune walkovers, spa, pools and the fine-dining restaurant Salt. The island's top-tier property and the base for the Amelia Island Concours d'Elegance week.
The 50-block downtown historic district on Amelia Island's river side, centred on Centre Street between 8th Street and the Fernandina Harbor Marina. Victorian storefronts, the island's densest concentration of restaurants and bars, and the Amelia Island Museum of History.
Details unconfirmed
The Atlantic side of the city of Fernandina Beach: Fletcher Avenue, Main Beach Park, Seaside Park, the numbered beach accesses, and the mid-size hotels and rentals behind the dune. Five minutes from downtown and directly on the sand.
Details unconfirmed
The resort half of Amelia Island: gated communities, golf, the Omni and Ritz-Carlton properties, and the quietest stretches of beach. Roughly everything south of Sadler Road down to Amelia Island State Park and the Nassau Sound bridge.
Details unconfirmed
An oceanfront condominium and resort district on Amelia Island's south end, between the Fernandina city limits and the Amelia Island Plantation area, containing the Ritz-Carlton and a cluster of rental condominium buildings behind the dune.
Details unconfirmed
The large planned resort community occupying much of Amelia Island's south end, now largely operated as the Omni Amelia Island Resort. Golf, villas, marsh-side trails, a nature centre and oceanfront behind the dune, inside a gated development.
Details unconfirmed
The Nassau County mainland immediately west of Amelia Island, across the Shave Bridge: the island's supermarkets, chain retail, big-box stores and the I-95 interchange, plus the route to Jacksonville airport and the Cumberland Island ferry.
Details unconfirmed
Off this map Yulee and the Mainland
This is the most consequential decision you will make about an Amelia Island trip, and it comes down to one trade-off: do you want to walk to dinner or walk to the beach?
Because on this island you cannot do both.
Amelia Island is thirteen miles long. Its historic downtown — the Victorian storefronts, the twenty-plus restaurants, the shops, the marina, the museum — sits on the Amelia River, on the island's western side. The Atlantic beaches are on the eastern side, about two miles away.
Visitors who book downtown expecting to walk to the beach are the single most common planning mistake here.
You get: Victorian inns and bed-and-breakfasts, a few small hotels, and the ability to walk to twenty kitchens, the bars, the marina, the shops and the museum. Sunset over the shrimp docks is at the end of your street.
You give up: the beach out of the back door. It is a two-mile drive or a longish walk east, and the beach parking fills by late morning in season.
Book here if: you are a couple on a short trip, you care about food and history, and a beach afternoon rather than a beach day is enough.
You get: the sand out of the back door. Plus golf, tennis, pools, spas, children's programmes, and the quietest beach on the island — the south end has no commercial development behind it, so the crowds are a fraction of the Fernandina accesses.
You give up: dinner variety. Resort dining is extensive and resort-priced, there is nothing walkable outside the gate, and downtown is a ten-to-fifteen-minute drive each way. A designated driver becomes a real consideration.
Book here if: it is a beach-first or golf-first trip, you are travelling with children, or you want a week where the car does not move.
You get: the beach, on foot, usually in under five minutes via one of the numbered public accesses. And downtown is a five-to-eight-minute drive, so Centre Street dinners are a casual decision rather than an expedition.
You give up: resort facilities. No golf, no spa complex, no kids' club, and pools belong to individual buildings. There is also no walkable restaurant district — a handful of casual beach grills and that is it.
Book here if: you want both halves of the island without committing to either. For a two- or three-night first visit this is usually the right answer, and most people never look at it.
| You want | Stay |
|---|---|
| Walk to dinner, drive to sand | Downtown |
| Walk to sand, drive to dinner | South end |
| Short drive to both | Oceanside Fletcher Avenue |
| Golf, spa, tennis, kids' club | South-end resorts |
| A porch and breakfast included | Downtown or oceanside inns |
| A kitchen and a week with family | South-end villas or condominiums |
Self-catering. A large share of the island's inventory is condominiums and houses with kitchens, concentrated on the south end. For a family or a week-plus stay that is the value play — but the supermarkets are on the mainland, fifteen to twenty-five minutes away in Yulee. Plan a shop on arrival day.
Festival weeks. The Shrimp Festival in early May closes downtown streets and fills every restaurant; the Concours d'Elegance in March does the same to the south end. If your dates collide with either, that argues for staying at the other end of the island — or for making the festival the point of the trip.
Nightly rates. They move daily and any figure here would be wrong by the time you read it. Nor ratings, ours or anyone else's — this site carries no review scores at all. See our editorial policy.
Part of Where to stay on Amelia Island.