Old Town is where Fernandina actually started, and almost nobody visits it.
It sits north of the modern downtown, and it is laid out on a Spanish plat of 1811 — reputedly one of the last towns platted under Spanish colonial rule anywhere in the New World. The grid, the block pattern and the Plaza San Carlos survive.
What you will find
A quiet residential neighbourhood. There are no shops, no restaurants and no visitor centre. What there is: the street grid itself, historical markers, the plaza, some very old houses, and a view over the Amelia River.
That is either a disappointment or the appeal, depending on what you came for. If you want to understand how this island was settled, standing in a Spanish plaza laid out in 1811 does more than a display case.
Why the town moved
The railroad. When David Levy Yulee's Florida Railroad arrived in the 1850s, its terminus and the deep-water wharves went south of Old Town, and the commercial centre followed. What is now the Centre Street historic district is the second Fernandina, built on railroad and shrimping money in the decades after 1875.
Old Town was left as a residential remnant, which is why so much of the early street pattern survived — nothing was rebuilt over it.
Bosque Bello Cemetery
The island's old burial ground, established in the Spanish period, sits nearby. It is worth twenty minutes: a live-oak and Spanish-moss cemetery with graves spanning the island's several nationalities, and one of the quietest places on Amelia Island.
Fort Clinch
The entrance to Fort Clinch State Park is at the edge of Old Town on Atlantic Avenue, which makes the two a natural pairing. Do the fort first while the light is good, then drive the Old Town grid and the cemetery on the way back.
Visiting respectfully
This is a residential neighbourhood, not an open-air museum. The houses are people's homes. Drive slowly, park considerately, read the markers, and do not go up anyone's path for a photograph.
Getting there
North on 8th Street and then following Atlantic Avenue and the signs for Fort Clinch. It is about five minutes from downtown Fernandina Beach.
What we have not confirmed
The exact 1811 plat date and the claim about it being among the last Spanish plats, the founding date of Bosque Bello Cemetery, and which specific structures in Old Town are the oldest. All are on our verification list — see our editorial policy for how that works.